The Price Nobody Picks: The Economist Decoy Experiment and Your Menu
When The Economist offered a print-only subscription nobody wanted, 84 of 100 students picked the bundle. Without it, only 32 did. Here's the classic decoy experiment, its limits, and an honest way to use it on your menu.
Imagine three subscription offers:
- Web only: $59 a year
- Print only: $125 a year
- Print + web: $125 a year
Nobody in their right mind picks "print only." It costs the same as the bundle and gives you less. So why would anyone put it on the page?
The experiment
In Predictably Irrational (2008), behavioral economist Dan Ariely describes finding exactly this ad on The Economist's website. He gave the same three options to 100 students at MIT's Sloan School of Management:
- Web only ($59): 16 students
- Print only ($125): 0 students
- Print + web ($125): 84 students
Then he gave a second group of 100 students the offer without the option nobody picked:
- Web only ($59): 68 students
- Print + web ($125): 32 students
The option that "nobody wanted" moved the bundle from 84 picks to 32 when it disappeared. In this hypothetical exercise, the print-only option made the bundle look like a free upgrade.
Researchers call this the decoy effect (or attraction effect): adding an option that is clearly worse than one of the others makes that other option look better.
The honest caveats
- It was a classroom exercise. Students made hypothetical choices; nobody paid for a subscription.
- It was not a restaurant study. The menu idea below is our takeaway.
- The effect has limits. In 2014, Shane Frederick, Leonard Lee and Ernest Baskin published "The Limits of Attraction" in the Journal of Marketing Research. Across many studies they found the decoy effect mostly shows up when options are described with numbers, and often shrinks or disappears when people judge real products by sight or taste. Food is about as "real product" as it gets.
So treat this as a lens for reading your menu, not a trick that is guaranteed to work.
What it means for your menu
The part that holds up best is the simplest one: what sits next to a price changes how it looks. Guests rarely judge a dish's price on its own. They compare it with whatever is next to it on the page.
- A $38 short rib next to a $95 steak for two looks reasonable.
- The same $38 short rib next to three $18 dishes looks expensive.
Nothing about the dish changed. Its neighbors did.
How to use this (honestly)
- Read each menu section as a set of neighbors. For every dish you want to sell more of, look at what sits directly above, below and beside it.
- Keep your top price real. A high-priced item should be something you're proud to serve and that some guests actually order. A fake "decoy" that guests can see through costs trust.
- Change one thing at a time. Move a dish, add or remove one option, then compare orders for a few weeks. If nothing moves, that's a useful answer too.
- Check what guests say about value. Your Google reviews already tell you which dishes feel "worth every penny" and which feel "pricey." That's the real-world test the classroom couldn't run.
Where Westify fits
Westify reads your Google reviews and turns them into reports on what customers keep saying, with real quotes. It also drafts replies you approve before anything is posted.
Want to try the reply side first? Our free tools (westify.app/tools) draft responses for up to 3 of your reviews, one time. And if you're writing replies yourself, start with our complete guide to responding to Google reviews (westify.app/blog/how-to-respond-google-reviews-complete-guide).
Sources
- Dan Ariely (2008), Predictably Irrational, HarperCollins, chapter 1, "The Truth about Relativity."
- Dan Ariely, "Are we in control of our own decisions?" TED (2008): https://www.ted.com/talks/dan_ariely_are_we_in_control_of_our_own_decisions/transcript
- Shane Frederick, Leonard Lee and Ernest Baskin (2014), "The Limits of Attraction," Journal of Marketing Research 51(4): 487–507. https://doi.org/10.1509/jmr.12.0061
The menu prices above are illustrative. We say nothing about The Economist's current prices. The restaurant takeaway is ours.
Related articles
The Hotel Towel Study: Why "Guests in This Room" Beat "Save the Planet"
ReadLocal Marketing, 4 minPhoto Reviews: Why They Build More Trust and How to Get More of Them
ReadLocal Marketing, 5 minThe Service Recovery Paradox: Fixing a Mistake Makes Guests Like You, but Not Necessarily Come Back
ReadStart with Westify
Plans from $29 a month
Get started