Domino's Put Its Worst Complaints on TV. What Restaurants Can Learn From the Pizza Turnaround
In 2009 Domino's aired focus groups calling its crust cardboard, rebuilt the recipe, and saw domestic (U.S.) same-store sales rise 14.3% the next quarter. Here's what happened, what it does and doesn't prove, and how to use your own bad reviews the same way.
Most brands spend their ad budget hiding what customers dislike. In December 2009, Domino's did the opposite: it bought national TV time to show its own customers trashing the pizza.
"Domino's pizza crust to me is like cardboard," one focus-group participant said on camera. Another said the sauce tasted like ketchup. Then the company announced it had started over.
What Domino's actually did
The campaign was called the "Pizza Turnaround." The TV spots put customers' complaints on air, and a longer documentary-style video online showed the real focus-group footage and the chefs rebuilding the recipe from scratch: a new crust, a new sauce and new cheese. The company's own team said the cardboard complaint was the one they heard most often.
The message was not "we're great." It was "you told us what was wrong, and we fixed it."
What happened next
Domino's reported its first-quarter 2010 results on May 4, 2010. For the quarter ended March 28, 2010, domestic (U.S.) same-store sales rose 14.3%, compared with 1.0% in the same quarter a year earlier. In its quarterly filing (Form 10-Q), the company called it the "largest quarterly domestic same store sales growth since our IPO." Domino's went public in 2004.
CEO J. Patrick Doyle put it this way: "A remarkably better pizza, and our honesty in how we told consumers about it, is paying off with a revitalized overall category – with Domino's leading that trend."
What this does and doesn't prove
Be careful with the lesson. The sales jump came from two things at once: a better product and a bold, honest campaign. Airing complaints alone would not have worked if the pizza had stayed the same. And the complaints came from focus groups, not from Google reviews.
So the takeaway is not "post your worst reviews in an ad." It is simpler:
- The complaints were the to-do list. "Cardboard crust" and "ketchup sauce" told the kitchen exactly what to fix.
- The fix was real. They changed the product, not just the message.
- They closed the loop in public. Customers heard that the company had listened.
Your reviews are already a to-do list
You don't need a focus group. Your Google reviews already tell you what guests keep noticing: cold fries, a slow Friday line, a loud room, a dessert that disappoints.
A practical routine:
- Read the bad ones first. One- and two-star reviews are where the specific fixes live.
- Look for repeats, not one-offs. One complaint is an opinion. The same complaint five times is a to-do item.
- Fix one thing, then say so. When you reply to a review about it, mention what you changed. Future guests read those replies too.
- Check again in a month. If the complaint stops showing up, the fix worked.
If you need help with the replies themselves, see our guide on how to respond to Google reviews (westify.app/blog/how-to-respond-google-reviews-complete-guide) or try the free tools (westify.app/tools) (you connect your Google Business Profile; the free reply tool covers up to 3 of your reviews, one time).
Where Westify fits
Westify reads your Google reviews and turns them into reports on what customers keep saying, including what to improve, with real quotes. It also drafts replies you approve before anything is posted.
Domino's needed a national campaign to learn what to fix. Your reviews are already telling you. The only question is whether someone is reading the bad ones.
Sources
- Domino's Pizza, Inc., "Domino's Pizza Announces First Quarter 2010 Financial Results," May 4, 2010 (SEC Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1): https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1286681/000119312510105392/dex991.htm
- Domino's Pizza, Inc., Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 28, 2010 (SEC): https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1286681/000119312510105403/d10q.htm
- Domino's, "Domino's® Pizza Turnaround" video, December 2009: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AH5R56jILag
- USA Today (Bruce Horovitz), "New pizza recipe did wonders for Domino's sales," May 5, 2010: https://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/industries/food/2010-05-05-dominos05_ST_N.htm
Domino's is not affiliated with Westify. The restaurant routine above is our recommendation, not something Domino's published.
Related articles
The Hotel Towel Study: Why "Guests in This Room" Beat "Save the Planet"
ReadLocal Marketing, 4 minPhoto Reviews: Why They Build More Trust and How to Get More of Them
ReadLocal Marketing, 5 minThe Service Recovery Paradox: Fixing a Mistake Makes Guests Like You, but Not Necessarily Come Back
ReadStart with Westify
Plans from $29 a month
Get started