← Back to blog
Local Marketing5 min readNovember 11, 2026

Same Mug, Different Price: What the Endowment Effect Study Means for Restaurant Rewards

In a classic experiment, students who were given a coffee mug wanted a median $7.12 to sell it, while buyers offered $2.87. Here's the study, its limits, and a careful way to apply it to the rewards your guests earn.

Hand someone a coffee mug, and something odd happens: the mug starts to feel worth more to them than it did a minute ago. Nothing about the mug changed. Only who owns it.

That's the idea behind one of the best-known experiments in behavioral economics, and it's a useful question for anyone who runs a rewards program for guests.

The experiment: sellers, buyers and choosers

In 1990, Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler published "Experimental Tests of the Endowment Effect and the Coase Theorem" in the Journal of Political Economy. One of its experiments (Experiment 6) went like this:

  • 77 students at Simon Fraser University were randomly assigned to three groups.
  • Sellers were given a coffee mug and asked, at a series of prices from $0.00 to $9.25, whether they would sell it.
  • Buyers did not get a mug and were asked, at the same prices, whether they would buy one.
  • Choosers did not get a mug either; at each price they simply chose between the mug and the cash.

The result: owning it changed the number

The median valuations were:

  • Sellers (owners): $7.12
  • Choosers: $3.12
  • Buyers: $2.87

Same mug, different starting point. The people who owned it wanted more than twice what buyers would pay. And because random assignment put roughly similar students in each group, the authors expected about 12.5 trades between buyers and sellers. Only three trades happened.

The choosers are the clever part. Like the sellers, they were really deciding between "mug" or "money". The only difference was that the sellers had been handed the mug first. Choosers valued it close to the buyers, not the sellers. The authors' conclusion: the gap comes mostly from a reluctance to give up something you already own, not a reluctance to pay. That's the endowment effect.

The same paper reports a follow-up (Experiment 7) with 117 students at the University of British Columbia, with price tags left on the mugs. The pattern held: median valuations of $7.00 for sellers, $3.50 for choosers and $2.00 for buyers.

A note on what these numbers are: they are valuations stated in an experiment, not retail prices and not average sales.

What it does not tell a restaurant

Be careful here. This study tested students and mugs. It did not test restaurant guests, loyalty programs, repeat visits or revenue. Nothing in it promises that a rewards program will bring guests back more often.

What it does offer is a good question to ask about your own program: does your guest feel they already own what they've earned?

Our practical hypothesis: make earned progress clear, then test it

This part is our application, not something the study tested. If ownership changes how people value things, a reward that feels like "mine" may matter more to a guest than one that feels abstract or hidden. A few low-cost ways to make earned progress easier to see:

  • Show the balance where the guest already looks. On the receipt, the card, or the screen at checkout: "You've earned 6 of 10" says more than nothing at all.
  • Use ownership language. "Your free coffee is waiting" reads differently from "eligible for a reward".
  • Don't hide the rules. If a reward has an expiry date or conditions, say so plainly. A reward that disappears without warning can feel like something taken away.
  • Tell your team. Staff who mention "you're two visits away" at the counter make the progress visible in person.

How to test it with your own guests

Because the study can't tell you what will happen in your restaurant, treat any change as a small experiment:

  1. Pick one change (for example, printing the reward balance on every receipt).
  2. Write down what you'll watch before you start: redemptions, repeat visits from members, or simply what guests say.
  3. Compare a period before and after, and keep everything else as steady as you can.
  4. Keep it or drop it based on your own results, not on the mug study.

Listen to what guests say about your rewards

Guests sometimes mention rewards or loyalty programs in their Google reviews, whether it's a card they enjoy or points they didn't know had expired. Those comments are free feedback on whether your program feels clear.

Westify reads your Google reviews and turns them into reports on what customers say, so recurring themes are easier to spot. It also drafts replies that you approve before anything is published. If you're starting with replies, see how to respond to Google reviews (westify.app/blog/how-to-respond-google-reviews-complete-guide) or try our free tools (westify.app/tools).

Fair caveats

  • This was a classroom experiment with students and mugs, not a study of restaurants or loyalty programs.
  • The figures are median valuations from Experiment 6 (and Experiment 7 for the follow-up), not typical prices.
  • The restaurant ideas above are our hypothesis to test. Results will vary by restaurant, guests and program.

Source

- Kahneman, D., Knetsch, J. L., & Thaler, R. H. (1990). Experimental Tests of the Endowment Effect and the Coase Theorem. Journal of Political Economy, 98(6), 1325–1348. https://doi.org/10.1086/261737 (Section IV, Experiments 6 and 7)

Start with Westify

Plans from $29 a month

Get started