← Back to blog
Local Marketing5 min readNovember 11, 2026

The First Number Sets the Price: The MIT Anchoring Study, Explained for Restaurants

MIT students who wrote down a high random number bid about three times more for the same wine. Here's the anchoring study, its caveats, and how the same idea shows up on your menu.

What would you pay for a decent bottle of wine? Before you answer, write down the last two digits of your social security number.

That second step sounds irrelevant. In a well-known study, it wasn't.

The study: "Coherent arbitrariness" (Ariely, Loewenstein & Prelec, 2003)

Dan Ariely, George Loewenstein and Drazen Prelec ran the experiment with 55 MBA students at MIT's Sloan School and published it in the Quarterly Journal of Economics.

Each student wrote the last two digits of their social security number next to a list of products, including bottles of wine and a cordless keyboard. For each item they answered one question: would you buy this for that many dollars, yes or no? Then they wrote down the most they would pay.

The digits were random. Nobody would argue that a social security number says anything about the value of wine. It still moved the bids.

  • Students with above-median numbers stated values between 57% and 107% higher.
  • Students in the top fifth of numbers typically bid about three times more than the bottom fifth.
  • For the average wine, that was about $28 vs about $9. For the cordless keyboard, about $56 vs about $16.

The authors called it "coherent arbitrariness": people are consistent once they have a starting point (a better wine still got a higher bid than a cheaper one), but the starting point itself can be almost arbitrary.

Why it happens

Most people don't walk in with a fixed price for a bottle of wine, a haircut, or a room upgrade. So they borrow one. The first number in front of them, even an irrelevant one, becomes the scale they judge everything else against.

Fair caveats

  • It was one group of business students, in a classroom, with a small set of products.
  • In 2014, Maniadis, Tufano and List re-ran a different experiment from the same paper (prices for annoying sounds) and found a smaller effect that wasn't statistically significant. Other researchers argued that replication was too noisy to rule out a real effect.
  • Anchoring in general has replicated many times, including in the large Many Labs project (Klein et al., 2014).

So treat it as a strong nudge, not a law of nature.

What it means for your menu (our take)

The study didn't test menus. This part is our application:

  1. Decide what the first price is. Whatever a guest reads first becomes the yardstick. If it's the cheapest side, everything after looks expensive.
  2. Lead with one big item. A steak for two, a tasting menu, a premium package. Few people need to order it. It makes the next prices read as fair.
  3. Keep the anchor honest. It has to be something you really sell and would be proud to serve. A fake "decoy" guests can see through costs trust.
  4. Apply it beyond food. Hotels: show the suite first. Barbershops: list the full grooming package above the basic cut.

The first thing guests see before your menu

For many guests, the first "number" is your Google profile: the star average and the last few reviews and replies. We can't promise any single reply changes a rating. A thoughtful, prompt reply shows that someone is paying attention, and an unanswered complaint leaves the guest to fill in the blanks.

If keeping up is the hard part, Westify drafts a reply to each Google review in your voice. By default nothing is published until you approve it. You can try the free review reply tool (westify.app/tools/google-review-reply-generator): connect your Google profile and it drafts replies to up to 3 of your most recent reviews. For the basics, see our complete guide to responding to Google reviews (westify.app/blog/how-to-respond-google-reviews-complete-guide) and how to reply to negative Google reviews with AI (westify.app/blog/how-to-reply-to-negative-google-reviews-with-ai).

Source

Ariely, D., Loewenstein, G., & Prelec, D. (2003). "Coherent arbitrariness": Stable demand curves without stable preferences. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(1), 73–106. doi:10.1162/00335530360535153

Replication: Maniadis, Z., Tufano, F., & List, J. A. (2014). One swallow doesn't make a summer: New evidence on anchoring effects. American Economic Review, 104(1), 277–290.

Start with Westify

Plans from $29 a month

Get started