← Back to blog
Local Marketing5 min readNovember 12, 2026

A Reminder Isn't a Plan: What the Flu-Shot 'Date and Time' Study Means for Restaurant Loyalty Copy

In a randomized trial at one U.S. employer, adding blanks for a date and time to a flu-clinic reminder lifted on-site vaccination from 33.1% to 37.1%: 4.0 percentage points, not 4%. Here's the study, its limits, and a careful way to test a concrete 'when' in your loyalty copy.

Most reminders tell people what is available and where. Very few ask them to decide when.

That small difference is the subject of a well-known field experiment run at one company's flu-vaccination clinics. It's worth knowing if you write reminders, loyalty messages or "come back soon" copy for your guests, as long as you're clear about what it did and didn't test.

The experiment: same reminder, two extra blanks

In 2011, Katherine Milkman, John Beshears, James Choi, David Laibson and Brigitte Madrian published "Using implementation intentions prompts to enhance influenza vaccination rates" in PNAS. The setup:

  • One large U.S. employer (the paper describes a Midwestern utility firm) offered free on-site flu clinics to its employees in fall 2009.
  • The study included the 3,272 employees who met the firm's eligibility criteria for the vaccine: age 50 or older, or certain chronic health conditions.
  • Every one of them got a reminder mailing with the dates, times and locations of the clinic at their work site.

Employees were randomly assigned to one of three versions of that mailing:

  • Reminder only (control): 1,268 employees.
  • Reminder + a prompt to write down the date and time they planned to get vaccinated: 1,270 employees.
  • Reminder + a prompt to write down just the date: 734 employees.

The prompt was just blank space on the mailer. Nobody booked an appointment, and any plans people wrote down were not shared with the researchers or the employer.

The result: 33.1% vs. 37.1%

The outcome was vaccination at the workplace clinic. Unadjusted rates:

  • Reminder only: 33.1%
  • Reminder + date and time blanks: 37.1%

That's a difference of 4.0 percentage points (the authors report a 95% confidence interval of 0.3 to 7.7 points, P = 0.04).

Read that carefully: 4.0 percentage points, not 4 percent. Going from 33.1% to 37.1% is four points on the vaccination rate. Calling it "a 4% increase" would misstate it.

The date-only version landed in between, at 35.6%, and that difference from the reminder alone was not statistically significant. The authors also report a regression-adjusted estimate, which is a slightly different number; we show the unadjusted rates here so the figures match each other.

The authors' interpretation: prompting people to plan a specific date and time, a technique psychologists call an implementation intention, made them more likely to follow through.

The limits worth knowing

The authors are open about the study's limits, and so should we be:

  • It's one employer, one season. The employees were mostly older and disproportionately male, at a single firm, and the trial ran in fall 2009, the season of the H1N1 outbreak. The authors say the population and the conditions that fall may limit how far the results generalize.
  • Some shots moved, not just added. The outcome was vaccination at the workplace clinic. The authors note that some of the extra workplace vaccinations displaced shots people would have gotten elsewhere.
  • It's vaccination, not restaurants. The study did not test restaurant guests, return visits, loyalty programs, retention or revenue. Nothing in it promises that a concrete "when" will bring guests back.

This post is about communication, not medical advice.

What it does not tell a restaurant

A date-and-time prompt nudged people toward a free, on-site clinic at their own workplace. A guest deciding whether to come back for dinner is in a very different situation: different motivations, different costs, many more options. The study can't tell you how big any effect would be for you, or whether there would be one at all.

Our practical hypothesis: test a concrete "when"

This part is our application, not something the study tested. Many loyalty messages stop at the "what": "You're one stamp away from a free dessert." The idea worth testing is adding a concrete "when" the guest can picture:

  • Vague: "Come back soon for your reward."
  • Concrete: "Your free dessert is waiting. Lunch on Thursday?"
  • Even more specific: "You're one stamp away. Thursday lunch works: we open at noon."

A few ground rules:

  • Keep it honest. Use real opening hours and real offers. Don't invent deadlines or scarcity.
  • Don't promise results. Treat the 4.0-point result as background, not a forecast for your restaurant.
  • Keep perks separate from reviews. Never offer a reward in exchange for a review, and never ask only happy guests to leave one.

How to test it with your own guests

Because the study can't predict what will happen in your restaurant, treat any change as a small experiment:

  1. Pick one message (for example, the text guests see on their loyalty card or at the register).
  2. Write two versions: the current one, and one that adds a concrete day or time.
  3. Decide what you'll watch before you start: stamps, redemptions, repeat visits.
  4. Compare a period before and after, keep everything else as steady as you can, and keep or drop the change based on your own numbers.

Where Westify fits

Westify's loyalty card lives in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, so guests can see their stamps on their phone instead of carrying a paper card. If you want to test clearer reward copy, it's a simple place to start. See the loyalty card (westify.app/loyalty-card).

Westify also replies to your Google reviews and turns them into reports on what customers say, so you can see which themes keep coming up. Replies are drafted in your voice. If you're starting with reviews, see how to respond to Google reviews (westify.app/blog/how-to-respond-google-reviews-complete-guide), read our post on the free chocolate study and restaurant rewards (westify.app/blog/zero-price-effect-free-chocolate-study-restaurant-rewards), or try our free tools (westify.app/tools).

Fair caveats

  • This was a randomized trial of flu-clinic reminders at one U.S. employer in 2009, not a study of restaurants, loyalty programs or customer retention.
  • The 33.1% and 37.1% are unadjusted workplace-clinic vaccination rates; the difference is 4.0 percentage points, not a 4% relative increase.
  • The restaurant ideas above are our hypothesis to test. Results will vary by restaurant, guests and message.

Source

- Milkman, K. L., Beshears, J., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., & Madrian, B. C. (2011). Using implementation intentions prompts to enhance influenza vaccination rates. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108(26), 10415–10420. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1103170108 (Table 2)

Run this with Westify

Nothing posts until you approve it.

Start with Westify

Plans from $29 a month

Get started