The "Most Popular" Table Sign Experiment, and Why Your Reviews Are the New Sign
A randomized experiment at a Beijing restaurant chain found that a 'top 5 most popular dishes' table sign raised orders of those dishes by 13–20%, while a plain list did nothing. Here's the study and what it means for your Google reviews.
Put two small signs on restaurant tables. One lists five dishes. The other lists five dishes too, ranked, under the words "most popular." Which one sells more food?
Economists actually ran this test, with real diners and real orders.
The experiment
In October 2006, Hongbin Cai, Yuyu Chen and Hanming Fang ran a randomized field experiment at a mid-priced restaurant chain in Beijing, across 13 locations and a menu of about 60 dishes. Their results were published in the American Economic Review in 2009.
Tables got one of two small plaques:
- The ranking sign: the five most popular dishes from the previous week, by number of plates sold, in ranked order.
- The plain sign: "some sample dishes from our menu," in random order. This list deliberately included the actual top dishes, just without the "most popular" label.
What happened
- The plain sign had no significant effect on what people ordered.
- The ranking sign raised demand for the top five dishes by about 13–20% (about 13% in a direct comparison and up to 20% after controlling for table position).
- The effect was a bit stronger for infrequent customers, the people with the least information.
- Diners at tables with the ranking sign also reported slightly higher satisfaction.
Same dishes, same restaurant. The only difference was knowing what other people had picked. Economists call this observational learning: when you're unsure, you follow the crowd's choices.
(Honest caveats: this is one chain, in one city, in 2006, and it measured dish orders, not reviews. The review takeaway below is ours.)
Your reviews are the "most popular" sign now
Most restaurants don't put a ranking on the table. But guests are already writing one for you, in your Google reviews:
- "Get the short rib."
- "The churros are unreal."
- "Order the dumplings, trust me."
New customers read those lines before they ever sit down. In practice, the dishes your reviewers keep naming become your "most popular" list, whether you planned it or not.
How to use this
- Find the dishes guests keep naming. Read your last few months of reviews and tally the dishes that come up more than once.
- Label them on the menu. A small "most ordered" or "guest favorite" tag on the dishes people already love is the same move as the ranking sign. Keep it honest: only label what actually sells.
- Make sure the kitchen nails them. If a dish is your public favorite, it needs to be consistent every night.
- Reply to the reviews that name a dish. A short, specific thank-you ("Glad you loved the short rib, it's our most ordered dish") reinforces the signal for the next reader.
Where Westify fits
Westify reads your Google reviews and turns them into reports on what customers keep saying, including which dishes they mention, with real quotes. It also drafts replies you approve before anything is posted.
Want to try the reply side first? Our free tools (westify.app/tools) draft responses for up to 3 of your reviews, one time. And if you're writing replies yourself, start with our complete guide to responding to Google reviews (westify.app/blog/how-to-respond-google-reviews-complete-guide).
Sources
- Hongbin Cai, Yuyu Chen and Hanming Fang (2009), "Observational Learning: Evidence from a Randomized Natural Field Experiment," American Economic Review 99(3): 864–882. https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.99.3.864
- Duke Today, "Diners Like to Follow the Crowd" (June 2009): https://today.duke.edu/2009/06/dining_study.html
- Yale ISPS data archive, study D050: https://isps.yale.edu/research/data/d050
The review examples above are illustrative. The restaurant takeaway is ours.
Related articles
The Hotel Towel Study: Why "Guests in This Room" Beat "Save the Planet"
ReadLocal Marketing, 4 minPhoto Reviews: Why They Build More Trust and How to Get More of Them
ReadLocal Marketing, 5 minThe Service Recovery Paradox: Fixing a Mistake Makes Guests Like You, but Not Necessarily Come Back
ReadStart with Westify
Plans from $29 a month
Get started