The Block List · New York
Best-rated bakeries in West Village, New York
How it's ranked: the 12 places a Google Maps search for this category shows within 1 km, ordered by star rating weighted by review volume. Listings under 30 reviews aren't ranked. Not Google Maps' own ranking.
West Village, New York
Bakeries · Top 12 by Google rating, weighted by review volume.
Loading the globe…
Drag to spin. Tap a city to zoom into its streets.
Bakeries in West Village, in short
The best-rated bakeries in West Village, New York, are Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods, Molly's Cupcakes and Benji's Buns. Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods leads the list with 4.8 stars across 310 Google reviews. We looked at 12 places within 1 km of the neighborhood's center. The 12 on this list add up to 6,223 reviews, with an average rating of 4.5.
West Village is number 3 of 5 neighborhoods in New York for bakeries, with a score of 4.65. The best neighborhood in New York for bakeries is Williamsburg (4.71).
Questions
What is the best bakery in West Village?
By this list, Janie's Life Changing Baked Goods: number 1 with 4.8 stars and 310 Google reviews. Next come Molly's Cupcakes and Benji's Buns.
How is this ranking built?
How it's ranked: the 12 places a Google Maps search for this category shows within 1 km, ordered by star rating weighted by review volume. Listings under 30 reviews aren't ranked. Not Google Maps' own ranking.
Which other neighborhoods in New York are good for bakeries?
- Williamsburg · 4.71 · #1 Levain Bakery
- SoHo · 4.70 · #1 Mille-Feuille Bakery Cafe
- Lower East Side · 4.64 · #1 Allan's Bakery
- East Village · 4.63 · #1 Unregular Bakery
Updated September 24, 2026 · Ratings and review counts from Google.
Other categories in West Village
Bakeries in other neighborhoods of New York
Is one of these yours?
Compare yourself with the rivals on your block, and let Westify reply to every Google review for you.