Too Good to Be True: Why a Perfect 5-Star Rating Can Sell Less
In real purchase data from three online stores, the chance of buying peaked around 4.2–4.5 stars and dipped closer to 5. Here's the study, its limits, and what it means for your imperfect reviews.
Most owners treat 5.0 as the finish line. Every 4★ feels like a crack, every 3★ like a disaster.
A study built on real sales data suggests the opposite: past a certain point, more stars stop helping, and a perfect score can even hurt.
The study: real purchases, not a survey
Ewa Maslowska, Edward Malthouse and Stefan Bernritter published "Too good to be true: the role of online reviews' features in probability to buy" in the International Journal of Advertising (2017).
Instead of asking people what they would do, they looked at what shoppers actually did. They used 2014 browsing and purchase data from three internet-only retailers across four product categories: light bulbs, women's athletic shoes, natural hair care and herbal vitamins. That is tens of thousands of product views and thousands of real orders.
What they found: an inverted U
More stars did mean more sales, but only up to a point. In the authors' words, "the probability of purchase increases with rating to about 4.2–4.5 stars, but then decreases."
For light bulbs and hair care the curve peaked around 4.2 and fell somewhat after that. For shoes and vitamins it rose to about 3.8–4, then flattened and declined. The authors put it plainly: a product averaging 3.8–4.2 stars was more likely to be bought than one with 5 stars.
Why perfect can backfire
The researchers' explanation is in the title. Shoppers may see near-perfect ratings as too good to be true, and may suspect the reviews were written by people from the company itself.
Their practical advice: it's "important to have some fraction of nonperfect reviews," and companies "should not censor negative reviews."
This lines up with Northwestern's Spiegel Research Center (2017), which found purchase likelihood peaks between 4.0 and 4.7 stars and then falls as ratings approach 5.0.
The fair caveat
This was online stores selling low-cost products, not restaurants, hotels or barbershops. The authors themselves note the results may not hold for other categories or pricier products. So it's not a promise that a 4.4 beats a 5.0 for your place.
But the lesson travels well: a profile with only perfect scores can read as curated. A mix of real experiences, including a few imperfect ones, reads as honest.
What to do with your imperfect reviews
- Don't panic about a 4★. It may be doing more for your credibility than you think.
- Never hide, bury or "manage away" criticism. Don't ask only happy guests for reviews and don't offer anything in exchange for them. Both break platform rules and erode the trust you're trying to build.
- Answer them. A calm, specific reply is the part future guests actually read. Thank the person, acknowledge the exact issue ("you're right about Friday"), say what you're doing about it, and invite them back.
- Keep it human. Skip "We appreciate your feedback." Use their words and one concrete detail.
If you want examples, see how to reply to negative Google reviews (westify.app/blog/how-to-reply-to-negative-google-reviews-with-ai) and the complete guide to responding to Google reviews (westify.app/blog/how-to-respond-google-reviews-complete-guide). You can also try the free Google review reply generator (westify.app/tools/google-review-reply-generator).
How Westify helps
Westify drafts a reply to each Google review in your voice and your language, including the 3★ and 4★ ones that are tempting to ignore. By default, nothing is published until you approve it.
Source
Maslowska, E., Malthouse, E. C., & Bernritter, S. F. (2017). "Too good to be true: the role of online reviews' features in probability to buy." International Journal of Advertising, 36(1), 142–163. https://doi.org/10.1080/02650487.2016.1195622 Supporting: Spiegel Research Center, "How Online Reviews Influence Sales" (2017).
Related articles
3 Google Review Replies to Stop Using (and What to Say Instead)
ReadOnline Reputation, 5 minRepeat Their Words: The Restaurant Study Where Echoing Orders Doubled Tips
ReadOnline Reputation, 16 min11 Best AI Reputation Management Tools for Small Restaurants (2026, Real Prices)
ReadStart with Westify
Plans from $29 a month
Get started