The Second Mint: What a Tipping Study Teaches About Replying to Reviews
In a restaurant study, a server who gave one mint, walked away, then turned back with a second one got the biggest tips. Same two mints. Here's what that teaches restaurants, hotels and barbershops about replying to Google reviews.
Why would a waiter walk away from your table, then come back with another mint?
Because, in at least one real restaurant, it earned the biggest tips of the night.
The study
In 2002, psychologists David Strohmetz, Bruce Rind, Reed Fisher and Michael Lynn published "Sweetening the till" in the Journal of Applied Social Psychology (doi:10.1111/j.1559-1816.2002.tb00216.x, doi.org/10.1111/j.1559-1816.2002.tb00216.x). In their second experiment, one server at an upscale restaurant in central New Jersey handed the check to 80 dining parties in one of four ways:
How the check arrived → Average tip:
- No mint → 18.95%
- 1 mint → 19.59%
- 2 mints at once → 21.62%
- 1 mint, the server starts to walk away, turns back and offers a second → 22.99%
One mint barely moved anything. Two mints helped. But the biggest tips went to the tables that got the same two mints, delivered as a little second gesture.
The authors' explanation is reciprocity: when someone does something for us, we want to give back. And the second mint felt extra. It felt like the server had decided, just for this table, to come back.
The lesson isn't "buy more mints"
A study about tipping doesn't prove anything about reviews. But the pattern is useful for any business that serves people:
- Automatic feels like nothing. One mint, handed over with every check, is part of the routine. Guests barely register it.
- Personal feels like a gift. The same mint, offered after a pause, looks like a choice someone made for you.
The difference isn't the size of the gesture. It's whether it feels meant for that person.
Your Google reviews are your tables
Think about what a review is. Someone finished their meal, their stay or their haircut, and then took a few more minutes to write about it. That's a guest at your table, still sitting there.
Most businesses do the "one mint" version: no reply, or the same "Thank you for your feedback!" on every review. It's automatic, and it reads that way. (We covered the replies to avoid in how to build a brand voice for review responses (westify.app/blog/build-brand-voice-review-responses).)
The "second mint" version is going back to the table:
- Use their name if they shared it publicly.
- Mention the thing they mentioned. The carbonara. The server. The view from room 4.
- Sound like you, not like a template.
Review: "Loved the carbonara. Our server Luca was great!" — Sofia R.
One-mint reply: "Thank you for your feedback."
Second-mint reply: "Thanks, Sofia! Luca will be thrilled. See you soon."
(Example from a demo business.)
And it applies to every review, not just the great ones. Here's why we think you should respond to every review, not just some (westify.app/blog/respond-to-every-review-not-just-some).
Restaurants, hotels, barbershops
- Restaurant: name the dish and the person who served it.
- Hotel: mention the detail they loved, the breakfast, the quiet room, the late check-out.
- Barbershop: mention the cut or the barber by name, and invite them back.
Where Westify fits
The hard part of the second mint is time. Writing a personal reply to every review, every week, is the first thing that slips.
With Westify, a review comes in and Westify drafts a reply in your voice. By default, nothing goes live until you approve it. You stay the one who goes back to the table. Westify just carries the tray.
Try it on your own reviews: our free Google review reply tool (westify.app/tools/google-review-reply-generator) connects to your Google profile and drafts replies to your 3 most recent reviews. No credit card. Plans start at $29 USD per location per month.
Source: Strohmetz, D. B., Rind, B., Fisher, R., & Lynn, M. (2002). Sweetening the till: The use of candy to increase restaurant tipping. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 32(2), 300–309.
Related articles
3 Google Review Replies to Stop Using (and What to Say Instead)
ReadOnline Reputation, 5 minRepeat Their Words: The Restaurant Study Where Echoing Orders Doubled Tips
ReadOnline Reputation, 16 min11 Best AI Reputation Management Tools for Small Restaurants (2026, Real Prices)
ReadStart with Westify
Plans from $29 a month
Get started